FREE SHIPPING with $75 Purchase - or - FREE with the L.L.Bean Mastercard 
‹ Back to L.L.Bean Men's Casco Bay Rugged Cotton Piqué Polo, Short-Sleeve, Untucked Fit
Customer Reviews for L.L.Bean Men's Casco Bay Rugged Cotton Piqué Polo, Short-Sleeve, Untucked Fit
View Product DetailsCustomer Reviews
What customers say:
Customers overwhelmingly praise these polos for exceptional comfort, style, and quality, with most noting the lightweight yet substantial fabric and relaxed fit ideal for warm weather. Many have purchased multiple colors and plan to reorder, citing durability and classic design with contrasting collar details. However, some reviewers express frustration with collar stiffness and creasing issues, while several in tall sizes report the shirt tails run noticeably short. A few mention shrinkage concerns and sizing inconsistencies. Despite these drawbacks, most customers consider these polos excellent and worth repurchasing.
AI Generated from customer reviews. Filter:
219 Reviews
Sort:
Verified Purchase
September 17, 2026
Love this shirt
Great quality and style! I would welcome more color options in future.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 17, 2026
The real thing lives up to the nostalgia
Weight: 130-140 lbs
Height: 5'6"
Size Purchased: Small
Used for: Travel, Paddling, Running or Fitness, Camping, Hiking
I had polos like this as a young man - not too thin, not too thick, the right fit and feel, the comfort of cotton and just an all-around great look on me. These Casco Bay polos hit
Kansas
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 17, 2026
Weight: 160-170 lbs
Height: 5'4"
Size Purchased: Medium
Used for: Casual or Every Day
We absolutely love shopping in the Mechanicsburg, PA store. It is always a pleasure. The store is always well organized, and the staff is always friendly, helpful, professional, an
Carlisle PA
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 11, 2026
Very comfortable and good-looking polo shirt
Very comfortable and good-looking polo shirt with the contrasting collar. I bought three different colors.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 8, 2026
Size, fabric
Weight: 200-210 lbs
Height: 5'10"
Size Purchased: Large
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I returned this shirt for an LL B Carefree Unshrinkable Polo Short Sleeve Without Pocket Men's Regular. Not sure if the Casco Bay was true to size. The sleeves seemed too short or
Oxford, MS
Was this helpful?
10
Verified Purchase
September 6, 2026
Shorty Shirt
A little too short for taller guys who, in the past, confidently bought a regular in the appropriate size. Great construction as we expect from LL Bean, and the color was as shown
Was this helpful?
10
September 6, 2026
Casco Bay is my favorite polo sold by LL Bean.
Size Purchased: Medium
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I like the contrasting color of the collar and sleeve band. Received compliments on this polo.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 5, 2026
High Quality Shirts
Weight: 220-230 lbs
Height: 6'1"
Size Purchased: X-Large
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Was looking to replace a couple of very old Izod shirts that were provided by my company and I asked ChatGpt where I could get high quality polo shirts. They suggested LL Bean. A
Was this helpful?
00
September 4, 2026
Terrible quality shirt
Weight: 180-190 lbs
Height: 5'9"
Size Purchased: Large
Used for: Relaxing, Casual or Every Day
This shirt is of terrible quality and is NOTHING like L.L. Bean's other polos (which I wear regualrly). Mine shrunk about 4 inches in length and two inches in the sleeves after one
Response from L.L.Bean
September 8, 2026
By L.L.Bean Customer Service
Thank you for your feedback. We are sorry that this polo was not what you expected. At L.L.Bean, we stand behind all our products. If you're not 100% satisfied with an item purchased directly from us, you can generally return or exchange it within one year with proof of purchase.
Princeton, NJ
Was this helpful?
01
Verified Purchase
September 3, 2026
This shirt caught my eye.
I got this shirt for my husband. He’s pretty picky about his polo shirts. He loved this shirt! It’s comfy, colors were great on him & his birthday is coming & I’ll be shopping
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 2, 2026
Casco Bay Short Sleeve Polo
Nice colors and fabric, but it is tailored for a fat person, almost as wide as it is long. Whatever happened to the slim fit?
Was this helpful?
00
August 30, 2026
Weight: 150-160 lbs
Height: 5'8"
Size Purchased: Medium
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I love the shirt because it is so comfortable. I already bought twice .However, I don’t see white and black color.
Texas
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
August 28, 2026
Quality of material is poor. Tall size is way too short compared to other polo shirts at LL Beans.
Was this helpful?
10
August 22, 2026
Probably the WORST Bean Shirt I've Ever Purchased
Weight: 270-280 lbs
Height: 6'3"
Size Purchased: XXX-Large
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Huge fan of LL Beans polos, except for this one. Collar is small/short and doesn't crease properly. Buttons are made of rubber and are a pain to button. Threw it away after about 1
New Hampshire
Was this helpful?
01
Verified Purchase
August 16, 2026
Comfortable Shirt
This is a very comfortable shirt, loving the dual color with the neck being a different color from the shirt. The fit is excellent.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
August 14, 2026
Buy bigger size
Height: 5'10"
Size Purchased: XXX-Large
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Doesn't fit as well as other polo shirts I have bought from Ll Bean. Seems to be made tighter.
Long Island
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
August 2, 2026
Nice shirt on cooler days
The shirt is attractive; however, it is heavier than what I was looking for.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
July 29, 2026
I thought this was an attractive polo shirt, and I am glad to have it.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
July 27, 2026
A Stylish Polo!
As with other LL Bean products, this polo looks great and is very well made.
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
July 27, 2026
Need to drop this style.
Weight: 220-230 lbs
Height: 5'11"
Size Purchased: X-Large
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Color and fit didn't work. Looked like an unhappy camper in it.
Response from L.L.Bean
August 1, 2026
By L.L.Bean Customer Service
We are sorry you did not care for the style of that polo. Our return policy generally enables customers to return products within one year of purchase. A member of our customer service team will be reaching out to you.
Colorado
Was this helpful?
20
Viewing 1 - 20 of 219
‹ Back to L.L.Bean Men's Casco Bay Rugged Cotton Piqué Polo, Short-Sleeve, Untucked Fit